Re: 1541 drive firmware confusion

From: Wolfgang Moser (womo_at_news.trikaliotis.net)
Date: 2008-08-16 10:51:05

Hi Jim,

Jim Brain schrieb:
> On the 1541-II, there is a version on Zimmers called the 
> 1541-II.355640-01.bin rom.  It's a c000-ffff rom, which is normal for 
> 41-II units.  The text notes it's only used on Newtronics mechs.

The Zimmers archive note for this ROM tells that
it was used in in 1541-II models with belt driven
mechanic -- to my knowledge, 4 different mechanics
were used in combination with the 1541-II (Chinon,
JPN, Newtronics and another one).

Although I do own such a belt driven 1541-II I
cannot find a ROM with this IC number around here.
So, probably, this IC number relation is no strong
rule?

> However, I split the file and did a compare to the other files.  It 
> appears this combined file is the same as:
> 
> cat 1540-c000.325302-01.bin 1541-e000.901229-05.bin > newfile
> 
> Which seems strange to me.  I would think the 1541-II would have had 
> some of the updates found in the other 1541-II drive

Yes, the release notes to the second ROM version
for the 1541C (1541B board) lists a lot of bugs
that were fixed for this later 1541C revision. And
these fixes must also be contained in the 1541-II
ROM with revision number -03.

http://www.zimmers.net/anonftp/pub/cbm/firmware/drives/new/1541/1541C.251968-02.txt

> Am I overlooking something?

Nothing that I would aware of. Maybe the Newtronics
mechanic needs a different handling or other timing
parameters that were destroyed by all the fixes for
the updated ROMs and therefore an older ROM version
was put into a 16kB ROM.


Womo

       Message was sent through the cbm-hackers mailing list

Archive generated by hypermail pre-2.1.8.